At the International Charter Expo (ICE) B2B trade show in Amsterdam, on 13 November 2025, the ICE Open Forum was held — a panel with the participation of representatives of the largest yacht charter companies Luka Šangulin (Angelina Yachtcharter, Croatia), Katerina Goutou (Fyly Yachting, Greece), and representatives of intermediaries Pavel Pribis (Boataround, OTA platform) and Max Barbera (Barbera Yachting, Germany), moderated by Tino Prosenik.
The forum opened with the presentation of four key topics: the imbalance of supply and demand, the problem of excessive price cutting, different commission models and real guest satisfaction. Prosenik also explained the dynamics of the conversation: each topic is introduced, panellists give their comments, after which the discussion opens to the audience, and ends with answers and a confrontation of views.
This framework immediately hinted that the conversation would touch on issues that have been shaping the market in recent seasons but are rarely raised publicly. The discussion that followed confirmed it: the industry has reached a moment where different interests and business models collide, and these four concepts show where the weak points are — but also where the solutions might be.
Supply-demand imbalance opens the discussion on industry sustainability
After the introductory presentation of the panellists, Prosenik opened the first chapter of the discussion — the imbalance of supply and demand. The topics were: uncontrolled fleet growth driven by yacht sales, the limited pool of customers, the question of who is responsible for its expansion, the possibility of shaping new service packages, and the challenges brought by digital platforms with growing influence on retail prices.
It was on this topic that Luka Šangulin first took the floor, opening the conversation from the operator’s perspective about what has actually been happening in the Mediterranean in recent years. The fleet is growing faster than demand, and that opens a whole range of questions — from price sustainability, through product differentiation, to who even has the responsibility to create new guests.
From the audience came a remark that further opened the discussion: the industry will hardly find new demand if it does not offer greater flexibility and a wider range of services. Experience so far shows that guests today expect the possibility of choice — different boarding days, shorter rental periods, tailored packages and clear rules that apply to all market participants. If further decline in occupancy and dependence on discounts are to be avoided, the market must enable guests to find what suits them more easily, and the rules of the game must be set unambiguously.
It is a stance that repeated throughout the whole discussion: the product has become too uniform, too limited to weekly cycles and too highly dependent on Saturday check-in, while growth in demand is expected that nobody is systematically building.
“Young people don’t see sailing. We are not loud enough.”
From the audience came a remark that opened the first real debate: sailing does not suffer from a lack of demand, but from a lack of visibility. The speaker warned that young people today make decisions on Instagram and TikTok, but sailing hardly exists there — for example, while #sailing has only a few million posts, other content has hundreds of millions. In his words, if the product is not seen, it does not exist for the new audience.
He also emphasised that the industry lacks the “media value” created by the guests themselves. Globally, around 1.5 billion dollars of sailing-related content value is generated, of which Croatia contributes about 200 million — too little for serious growth. He sees the solution in actively encouraging guests to share photos and videos, and in joint campaigns of operators, brokers and platforms. “When the amount of content grows, the top of the funnel widens, and with it the market,” he concluded.
Operators: “Price is our responsibility. If we lose it, we lose the product too.”
After the discussion on visibility and creating demand, Prosenik directed the panel to the second key question — price. He reminded everyone of the conclusions from the previous day, when representatives of the 15 largest operators and 15 brokers discussed in the closed part of the forum, and when it was already emphasised that it is the operators who determine the value of their product and the strategy by which they manage it. Although fleet growth created pressure and encouraged phenomena like price cutting and reliance on discounts, Prosenik stressed that responsibility for price cannot be handed over to others, nor is it possible to expect every market to function the same.
So he opened a new topic with a question to the operators: do they agree that a boat’s price cannot be the same in all countries, and that the discount strategy must follow the characteristics of each destination, costs and demand dynamics? It was exactly at that point that the discussion reopened — this time around who actually has the right to touch the price and how far adaptations may go.
The operators very clearly emphasised that the price must remain under their control. Šangulin said the mistake of the whole industry was the attempt to “cover costs by lowering prices”, which led to a situation where a boat is sometimes cheaper than it should be.
He explained that different regions have different costs — from marinas to management fees — so it is logical that the same type of boat costs more in one destination and less in another. The problem arises when the pricing strategy collapses under the pressure of discounts: a price that has been lowered once is almost impossible to bring back to a realistic level.
Another important message repeated throughout the discussion: when the price collapses once, the guest learns to wait for a discount. If they are offered a realistic price the following year, they perceive it as a price increase. That is exactly why operators believe the market should protect the “lowest sustainable price” instead of competing on who can go lower.
Commission is not a discount — and the industry too often treats the two as the same
One part of the discussion particularly emphasised something that has been wrongly equated in the industry for years — commission and discount are not the same thing, although in practice they are often used as if they were.
The panellists warned that commission refers to the fee for the work of intermediation, while a discount is a direct intervention in the price of the product. When those two things get mixed, chaos ensues: the operator no longer knows the real minimum price of their boat, brokers create a “race to the bottom” among themselves, and OTA platforms only further accelerate the fall of the displayed price in the system.
It was also emphasised that the misuse of commissions leads to another dangerous situation: a discount granted by a broker or OTA platform is actually attributed to the operator, and the guest doesn’t know who lowered the price. This erodes trust, and the operator loses control over the perception of their own value. The panellists’ conclusion was unambiguous — commission should remain a tool of cooperation, and discounts exclusively in the hands of operators, because only that way can the price remain sustainable.
Brokers: “We sell their product, we must not change it.”
From the brokerage side, several very clear positions were heard. Max Barbera was very clear and decisive: he said no discount that changes the price of a boat should be possible — not one percent, not five, not fifteen. In his view, the only sustainable logic is that the operator determines the price, and the broker competes on quality of service, not depth of reduction.
Other participants confirmed that part of the market deviations happen precisely because of mutual competition among brokers, not because operators want discounts. In some cases the operator can no longer sell a boat even at their direct price, because the market has already seen a lower amount through a third party.
It was also noted that a certain part of the market does not react to price at all. There are buyers who choose the brand of the charter company, the destination, the boat type or a known service — not the lowest amount. It follows that the industry focuses too much on those looking for the lowest price, instead of on those looking for quality.
OTA perspective: “We don’t lower the price — we only show what appears in the system.”
Pavel Pribis, representative of a large OTA platform, tried to explain his position: in his words, the platform does not lower prices, it only shows what brokers or operators offer. If a lower price appears somewhere, the system shows it because the guest expects transparency.
He also emphasised that OTA platforms have both advantages and weaknesses. It is easy to scale content and reach a wider audience, but it is hard to maintain the quality of communication and support in every time zone. He also said the platform is working on improving customer support and that it is still, in part, “catching up with its own growth”.
But those explanations did not entirely calm the hall. One operator openly said that it was precisely because of that way of displaying prices that he terminated cooperation with the platform, stating that he had to protect his product and brand.
The audience: “We ended cooperation because we must protect our product.”
The most honest moment of the panel happened when an operator from the audience said he had ended cooperation with an OTA platform after a series of situations in which prices appeared on the internet that had never been approved from the fleet.
He explained that guests started sending screenshots with non-existent prices, and he realised he could not simultaneously maintain fleet quality and compete with discounts he had not approved.
“At the end of the day, the guest thinks we are raising the price or hiding something. And we are just trying to stick to our own rules,” he said.
“We are not selling sailing, we are selling hospitality.”
One of the more notable interventions came from an operator in the audience, who explained that the industry had been convincing itself for years that it is still a “sports” product, although reality changed long ago.
He recounted that already ten years ago he started filming boats, collecting reviews and building a B2C approach, because guests are not skippers — they are tourists. He warned that sailing is no longer a “closed club of sailors”, but a tourist product that must be presented and promoted as an experience, not a technical package.
This view caused a strong reaction from the audience, partly because it is exactly what many feel, and partly because it opens the question of a serious transformation of the industry.
The bigger picture: time for standards, categories and a long-term plan
Towards the end of the forum, the audience also raised a topic few dare to warn about publicly: the industry has no standards.
There is no boat categorisation, no clear service levels, no unified system for displaying photos or technical condition. In such an environment, the only reference value becomes price.
One participant warned that without a long-term strategy there is a risk of the market falling under the domination of one large platform, as happened in other industries. Others, however, said that operators still hold the key cards — without their boats there are neither platforms nor brokers.
A realistic presentation of the offer and fast support are the key to guest satisfaction
In the final part of the panel, Prosenik opened the topic of guest satisfaction, reminding everyone that a day earlier among brokers the prevailing opinion was that guests are, generally speaking, satisfied. But he immediately asked a follow-up question: what is still missing and where can progress be made?
The brokers were direct. According to them, the situation is solid but far from perfect. They explained that they cooperate exclusively with fleets for which they can guarantee a minimum standard — clean boats, proper equipment and a fast reaction when something goes wrong. “If you display a perfect boat at a trade show and the guest arrives to a completely different condition, that is simply bad business,” they said. That is exactly why they avoid operators who cannot consistently deliver what they show.
The OTA platform representative followed up with concrete examples. The most common source of dissatisfaction arises when photos do not match reality — guests expect a TV, air conditioning or certain equipment because they saw them in the listing, and on the spot they learn it doesn’t work or the boat doesn’t have it at all. “It’s like booking a hotel without knowing what the room looks like,” he said.
Although many destinations, especially Croatia and Italy, have significantly improved photos and fleet presentation in recent years, the problem still exists. A large part of the content is outdated, consistency is lacking, and differences between real and displayed conditions still create a gap in expectations. OTA platforms therefore increasingly send their own photographers, but emphasise that without active cooperation from operators that gap will not disappear.
The message was unanimous: guest satisfaction today largely comes down to “alignment of expectations”. If photos, descriptions and product presentation do not match the actual state, no price, discount or marketing campaign can fix it.
After the discussion about fleets, prices, commissions and visibility, almost everyone agreed on one thing: in an industry that changes from season to season, those with the strongest relationship with the guest survive in the long run. Everything else — cooperation models, digital channels, discounts and platforms — are just tools that can help or damage that relationship.
Finally, as Čarter.hr we want to remain a place where such topics can be heard clearly and without filters. We will continue talking to people from the industry, seeking explanations where they are missing, and offering concrete guidelines where we know they can help. If the industry wants a more stable and healthier way forward, conversations like these must not remain the exception but become the standard.