If you work in the charter industry, you have surely come across reviews like: “Everything was great, but… the skipper wasn’t communicative.” “The boat was nice, but… the air conditioning didn’t work.” “The staff was kind, but… we waited too long for check-in.”
If a guest says everything was great, then I guess it was. At first glance, reviews like this can sound positive. But they are not… They also leave a bad impression on those who read them. And those are your potential guests. And those potential guests, like most people, look for that “but” and read between the lines.
Even such, seemingly praising reviews, which can even have 5 stars but contain criticism, actually lower the average rating in the eyes of others, discourage new enquiries and leave a bad impression on future guests.
You must no longer ignore such reviews.
What that “but…” actually means and why it is dangerous for you
When a guest writes: “Everything was great, but…”, that is not a compliment. It is a message that you were close, but not close enough. Such reviews mean the guest had every intention of being satisfied, but something spoiled the impression.
And that “something” is usually a small thing that could easily have been fixed or prevented.
The worst part is that a guest with a “but” review won’t argue much or ask anything of you — they will simply choose another charter next time.
They will tell their friends: “It was okay, but…” — and there ends every chance of a referral.
But every business, including charter, depends on trust and reputation. Some reviews don’t look bad until you look at them closely, but they slowly and imperceptibly spoil the picture of you.
Such reviews most often:
Lower the average rating. A four looks good, but a five is a five.
Turn away insecure guests. When someone researches offers, every doubt can be decisive.
Create an impression of inconsistent quality. The guest wonders whether they will have “that” problem from the review.
Show that you overlooked something. And small things matter a lot — you don’t want to leave the impression that you don’t care.
Today’s guests don’t only look at the rating, but also at the tone of the comment. If every other review has a “but”, it is clear that some things need fixing.
The most common reasons for “but…” in reviews
Nobody is asking for perfection, but guests remember exactly those small things you think are not important. And it is precisely those that decide whether a review will be a clean five or will instead be: “Everything was great, but…”
In most cases, behind such comments stands a small thing that was not resolved in time, and that spoiled the whole experience for the guest.
The most common reasons behind “but” comments:
Weak communication before arrival. If a guest waits days for an answer, or has to look for basic information themselves, trust is lost from the start. Speed and tone of communication are sometimes more important than the content of the message itself.
Confusing check-in or check-out. Guests are already tired from the journey. If they get unclear instructions, if nobody properly welcomes them or they feel lost, they will remember it. And mention it in a review.
Cleanliness and technical condition of the boat. A single stain, a smell in the cabin or a minor fault is enough for the guest to conclude that no care is taken over details. They don’t know whether you had 10 or 110 check-ins that day — they only care about their boat.
Unrealistic expectations. If the photos show luxury and luxurious equipment and extras, and the reality is average or parts are missing, disappointment is guaranteed. The guest doesn’t distinguish marketing from truth — what they see is what they expect.
Staff mood. Even the best boat will look worse to a guest if it is handed over by someone who is listless. Guests feel that immediately.
None of these are big problems, but together they create the impression that something is off. And that feeling is what the guest expresses with… well, you know.
If such comments keep repeating, it means the problem is not random but systemic. That means the slips and mistakes are not accidental — they are rooted in the way of working or the organisation of the business.
And those “but” reviews are your best indicator. You must start listening to what guests are telling you and fix what persistently bothers them, until that “but” is erased from every next review.
Every contact with a guest is a chance to improve the impression
The whole experience for a guest doesn’t begin when they step onto your vessel — it begins much earlier, at the first enquiry. And it doesn’t end with check-out, but at the moment they decide whether they will recommend you or not.
Everything in between (emails, phone calls, welcome, staff mood, communication during the trip) goes into the final grade. And the review is a summary of all of that.
So every contact should be seen as a chance to leave a good impression — not to “buy” a 5-star review, but so the guest sees someone’s honest effort.
Here is what you can concretely improve:
Replies to enquiries. Reply quickly, but not with templates. Let the answer be clear and tailored to that person — at least address them by name. Guests immediately recognise when they are being sent a “copy-paste” answer.
Offers. Instead of sending a PDF without any explanation, write a short message. Explain why you are proposing exactly that boat, suggest the best routes too. Show that you read what the guest is asking for.
Check-in. Welcome the guest properly. Not in a rush, not with an eye on the clock. A good check-in implies a sense of welcome and security. Clearly explain the basics, without a “you already know that” approach.
Technical support. If something doesn’t work, who answers the guest’s call? If a guest has to call three numbers and wait for hours, you won’t avoid a “but” review. You must have a person on call who knows your fleet and can give a solution.
Return to base. Don’t just take the keys and say “goodbye”. Ask the guests how it was. Thank them for their trust. Ask what impression they are taking home and, if they were satisfied, ask if they would be willing to leave a review.
When guests feel that someone truly paid attention to them, that stays. That impression stays.
You set the expectations — and that starts before the guest books
People often arrive at your base with an already formed opinion.
They have a picture in their head, which they didn’t necessarily come up with themselves — they are guided by what they saw on your website, Instagram profile, in the offer you sent them.
And that is where the problem arises.
If what they saw doesn’t match what they get, they will be disappointed — even if the vessel they booked is perfectly fine.
Your guests don’t compare you to the competition there — they compare you to what you yourself showed them.
That is why it is important to communicate as realistically and as close to the real experience as possible. No need to exaggerate — be honest and clear.
What you can do better:
Photos — don’t use retouched images that don’t show the boat’s real condition. Better to show the cabin with real light and layout than a decorated but unrealistic photograph.
Descriptions — instead of the usual sentences like “top comfort” or “unforgettable experience”, write concretely what the guest can expect. Does the boat have air conditioning? What is the mattress like? How much space is there really in the cockpit?
Reviews — don’t hide comments in which guests mention things you have since fixed. Such reviews actually show that you listen and react. That is worth more than 5 stars.
Social media — publish content showing real moments from the boat and the base. People love seeing how things actually look. Let posts not be just ads, but useful, informative and simple. For example: what the parking in front of the base looks like, where the nearest shop is, what to bring for children.
When a guest knows what awaits them, they will be more prepared and more satisfied. If expectations are aligned with reality (or slightly below, so guests are positively surprised), you can expect a genuinely good review.
You will no longer have to read “everything was great, but…” because that “but” will no longer exist.
Your employees are the face of your company. But do they know that?
A guest doesn’t care who owns the company, who runs the base or who is responsible for communication. They care about how someone greeted them, how the important things were explained to them, whether they had someone to ask a question, and whether someone said “thank you for coming”.
That is why your employees — all those who are in contact with guests — are the most important link in the chain.
If someone was rude or uninterested, the guest won’t write: “Person X was unprofessional.” They will write: “They were not kind at charter X.” — and that will apply to your whole charter company.
If your people don’t know how important they are in that process, if nobody told them that they are the ones shaping the impression of the whole company, they will hardly think of it themselves.
That is why you must prepare them and include them.
What that concretely means:
Training — people won’t and can’t do what nobody asks of them. Introduce short trainings on how to communicate with guests. It doesn’t have to be anything formal — it is enough to sit down once a month and go through what was good and what can be better.
Empathy — explain to employees that the guest doesn’t know how tired they are, how many boats they handed over and which way the wind is blowing that day. The guest only sees them, and if someone acts cold or angry, that stays in the guest’s memory.
Feedback — when a good review arrives mentioning your employee, show it to that person. Share praise and thank them. If a guest mentions something negative, don’t attack — talk. You need to know and hear your employees, not call them out.
Clear expectations — write down concretely what you expect from everyone who works with guests. Don’t assume everything is “implied”. A polite tone, a clean shirt, a fast reaction — these are things that need to be said aloud, and if needed, repeated.
When staff behave as if the company is theirs, guests notice. But if it shows that they are only there to do their shift, that is noticed even faster. And all of it will be visible in the reviews.
How to encourage authentic 5-star reviews
You won’t get a good review just because the boat was clean and the skipper professional. Most guests won’t even think of leaving a review unless reminded.
So you shouldn’t beg for a review — you should create conditions in which the guest wants to do it.
If a guest feels respected and noticed in your charter, they will set aside five minutes and write something positive.
Here is what you can do to increase the number of quality reviews:
Communication at check-out — when the guest returns the boat, try not to rush. Ask the guest sincerely how it was. Thank them for choosing your charter. Show that you are interested in both their opinion and impressions.
Follow-up message — send a short email or message a day or two after the guest’s departure. Don’t make it a generic text — a message with their name and a link for the review. Example: “Dear Mr. Marko, thank you for sailing with us last week. We hope you had a great time. If you have a minute, share your impressions here.”
Make the process easy — if a guest has to go through five steps for a review, they probably won’t write it at all. Give a direct link, without the need to search for where to click.
Engage employees — if communication with the guest was good, that same employee can say on departure something like: “Your feedback really helps us, so if you don’t mind, you can leave a short review.” Without asking for five stars, without pressure — just a reminder. People appreciate being addressed with respect.
Reward the effort — if a guest leaves a review, thank them, but not generically — personally. You can also offer a small token of appreciation, like a discount on the next booking.
When you have honest and concrete reviews, you can clearly see your guest’s perception — because you see what you are doing well and where you can still grow.
A pile of 5-star reviews is not a goal in itself — it is the result of the relationship you build with guests.
Time for reviews without “but”
If you have those reviews that say “but”, it means you have a problem nobody recognised. Or they recognised it, but didn’t react.
Guests see it. And write about it. Not to be mean, but to leave a comment about what bothered them.
Read your reviews. Respect what is written. And react.
Here is what you can concretely do:
Review the patterns — read the last 10–20 reviews. Don’t just look at the rating, look at what is mentioned. Is communication often mentioned? Check-in? The crew? Those are points you can act on immediately.
Don’t downplay “small” comments — if several guests say the boat was good but the air conditioning didn’t work, that might also be a communication problem. Maybe they didn’t know how to turn it on. Maybe nobody checked that everything was functional.
Make an internal comment list — keep notes about every guest who noticed something, good or bad. After 5–10 you should have a clear picture of your biggest problems.
Give the team feedback about reviews — if a guest praises the skipper or someone from the base, say so. People try harder when they know their effort is noticed.
Write a short message for departure — when the guest leaves the base, and let everyone use the same short message, e.g. “If you need anything, let us know, we are here for you.”
A good reputation is not built on pretty pictures or occasional 5-star reviews. It is built on consistency, a human approach and readiness to accept the real state of things — even when it is not pleasant.
In the end, the question is very simple…
Will you read next time:
“Everything was great.”
…or again:
“Everything was great, but…”?
That doesn’t depend on the guest. It depends on how you organised the business, how you communicate and how much you care about the impression you leave.
Every review is just the result of your everyday work — nothing more and nothing less.
If you think your reviews don’t reflect the real quality of your service, you are not alone.
That is exactly why at Čarter.hr we help charter companies present better what they already do well and fix what bothers guests — which often isn’t visible from the inside.
Do you need a realistic assessment of your online impression?
Do you want clear suggestions on how to improve communication, presentation and feedback?
Get in touch. We work with charters that want to hear only one thing: “Everything was great.” Full stop.